Class is What Capitalism Makes of It: Challenging the Lure of ‘‘Realism’’ in Mainstream Class Analysis
Release time: 2020-09-08
Guillaume Durou
Abstract
This article addresses polemically, perhaps, the most prominent class analyses today – the occupational and stratification approaches (OSAs) developed by various sociologists and economists. Strongly opposed to the “big class” of conventional Weberian and Marxian typologies, the stratification and occupational models have, unsurprisingly, claimed more realistic grounds. By contrast, key dimensions of social relations such as domination, exploitation and oppression are purposely overlooked. Moreover, the lack of theorization – even marginally regarded, does not take into consideration the qualitative explanatory strength for the analysis of social structure. Alternatively, the underlying optimistic market-oriented belief of the “realistic” class framework overestimates the role of institutions and economics. Thus, this “Smithian” background unveils a market fetishism as well as a functionalist and naturalized vision of class structure.
Keywords
Capitalism, class analysis, class theory, Marxism, work and economy
From: Critical Sociology 2020 46 (2)
Editor: Wang Yi